AAR Reviews DEMON ANGEL!

 

Okay, maybe it’s dumb to put an exclamation mark after that, but … WOOT! My book just got reviewed at AAR!!

It means a ridiculous amount to me — only in the last two years have I been active in a romance reading community, lurking for a long, long time at sites like AAR, TRR, and Mrs. Giggles … but mostly AAR. And I’ve gotten lots of recommendations, but the most important thing? Having people articulate what did and didn’t work for them in a romance novel. Because I’m not very good at it.

And as a writer, I think it’s invaluable to have some way of articulating where a story is going wrong — a lot of it is instinct: you get stuck, and you realize your character did something out of character, or your plot has gone off the wall or it stalled — and NAMING those problems, really being able to SAY what they are instead of just going by instinct is something I should have picked up in the thousands of books I’ve read (I didn’t, though) and a freaking degree in literature … those books let me recognize it, not really name it.

And it’s easier to kill what’s wrong if I know exactly what it is.

Anyway, for a girl in 1997 who was pretty lonely in Anchorage, AK, who used to sneak in to work at Deloitte & Touche at midnight to use the Internet and read X-Files and X-Men fanfic, and didn’t know anyone else who read romance, but one day happened to stumble across AAR while looking up more books by Katherine Kingsley, whose NO GREATER LOVE I’d just fallen in absolute love with … it was the best thing ever.

And my goal in life is getting a DIK there, dammit. (Okay, not really, I’d like that a lot, sure, but my real goal in life is just writing books that I love, forever and ever. Oh, and one day, to stop after eating Just One Potato Chip.)

(Demon Angel got a B-, but I think it was a good review.)**

—-

**And I’m laughing like crazy because the part that I thought had the most problems, the reviewer liked best. Hee, I’ll never be able to predict people.

But still, the best part was going to the message boards and reading that a reader had really liked it. And I’m still giggling because she liked best the same part, too.

….and now I’ve got to stop doing that.

10 comments

1|

Meljean – I saw the review for your book there. Congratulations!!! While of course one would want a DIK every time out, the reviewer had some pretty positive things to say. I think for me the hardest part would be reading what other people have to say. I know I’d be reading with my hands covering my eyes!
And has one ever been able to eat Just One Potato Chip? That’s one of the hardest things of all!

2|

congrats MB! I’m pretty sure the readers will enjoy your book even more so than the reviewers, its all about them after all! The message boards will cetainly light up with opposing views on your book. They’ll probably say that the reviewer was wrong for giving your book a B, they’ll say…she deserves an A + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + ! Readers aren’t as critical they just want to be entertained. =)

3|

Kristie — I’m such a dork, but it’s pretty cool. And I thought the review was really positive, too; it’s hard to be disappointed when I knew there were structural points that would stick with some readers, and that she also called it “consistently intriguing and often fascinating” … really, it’s hard not to like that :)

Long Tran — LOL! Thanks! … although I know plenty of critical readers … ;) And a B- at AAR isn’t a bad thing at all, IMHO. It’s a recommendation with reservations … but still a recommendation.

4|

Congratulations!! Hmm. . . maybe you need to write some novellas covering those “early” years of Hugh and Lilith? :wink:

5|

Congrats Meljean, what did I tell you. *wink*

6|

Meljean,

Very interesting. I used to work for Deloitte Consulting, now known as Deloitte.

BTW I went to B&N and Demon Angel sold out. Grr…they told me I have to wait until next week.

7|

A nice review from AAR and a sold-out report besides?! All right, Meljean! Congratulations!

8|

So very very cool. B- is really a very good review! I’d read an AAR B- book with no reservations.

Mine’s on it’s way from Amazon. Puleese oh puleese come soon.

9|

Congratulations, Meljean!

10|

Congrats Meljean and it tickles me that you are tickled by an AAR review – I would think that that means a romance author has arrived! ;)

Can’t wait to get my copy. Just waiting for all these extra people running around to go back to work and school and just leave my bookstores alone!

CindyS